Home
- - - - - - -
About David Batstone
Saving the Corporate Soul
Consulting Services
Speaking Events
- - - - - - -
WAG
Right Reality Blog
Articles
Press
- - - - - - -
Contact David Batstone
Store
- - - - - - -
RSS


Subscribe to the WAG
Email:
Zip:
 

 


Why Do People Still Wait in Lines? Print E-mail
Written by David Batstone   

The new de Young Museum in San Francisco opened up this month and throngs of people waited in line to be one of the first to see its classy design and fresh exhibitions. Amazed at the public response, local columnist Joan Ryan, wrote a column in the San Francisco Chronicle under the title, "Americans Still Seek the Authentic." Ryan penned a profound observation: "Americans are hungrier than ever for the beautiful and the authentic, for experiences that challenge what we know, for ideas that show us the world from a new angle."

I would go one step further: Even though we enjoy nearly unlimited access to information and communication, we desire real experience. We want to the THERE when creativity happens. Marketers would do well to pay attention to this phenomenon. Goods and services so easily pass into commodities; experiences, on the other hand, leave memories.

Why else would hundreds of thousands of people wait in the cold of the night to buy the latest Harry Potter book? After all, Amazon promised that it would not run out of Half-Blood Prince and get it to our doorstep at first release. But the one thing that Amazon could not deliver is the memory of being THERE and telling your friends for years to come about that moment. Anyone can be a consumer. To take part, now that begets a unique individual.

Not every product, or event, yields an experience, however. Consider the fact that ticket sales for the majority of rock shows are down. The U2 tour, on the other hand, sells out nightly and turns into one of the hottest tickets at every stop. Ask anyone who has attended a U2 concert what happened. Trust me, they will gush on how it made them feel - inspired, elated, connected, and the like. That is not just happenstance. Months before they go out on tour, the band and their show designers consciously set out to create a community of participation.

Jumping venues, the online world, in my humble, has tapped out its usefulness as a static kiosk. Yes, it's a terrific reference librarian, retail outlet, and one-stop data shop. But the next quantum growth for the Internet will arrive with participation technologies that give us the tools to transform our lives. In truth, the Net as a communications platform has been my sense of its real potentiality all along. It is the first glimpse of an emerging economy. You give me the tools to make my own personal history, to change my life, to feel in a new way, to participate in something authentic, you will own a piece of economic value.

Observing my own kids, I am convinced that this dynamic is in no small part driving the IPod craze. They spend hours with their friends debating which songs to download if not swapping their favorites. Crafting a unique mix offers all the ingredients of expressing their personal identities. The IPod transforms them into the music producer as well as the consumer.

Tools of participation - that is the new economy. You cannot package an authentic experience. You set the stage and let people script their own dramas.

Comments
Add NewSearchRSS
Laura Young - YES YES YES! Excellent articl
2005-10-26 10:35:12
David, I think you nailed this one. I just had 2 conversations yesterday on this very issue, along with some commentary from another journalist over at my blog about this dance we are doing between between the more removed aspects of the virtual world and this craving for intimacy and real experience, particularly creative experience that people are expressing.
In fact, I had to laugh about your iPod commentary as I had a friend just this weekend tell me he was going to burn a CD and leave it on our porch. A sort of personal soundtrack. Of course, what struck me was that he was going to leave it one the porch and run away really fast (I want you to see me, no, wait, don't look!).
I could write to you for hours on this, weaving together so many conversations I've been in the last few months with artists, corporate folks and everything in between, not to mention my experience accidentally ending up in the middle of Muggleville (yes, accidentally, all I wanted was Cuban food, it seemed so simple at the time).
I'm looking forward to seeing how the conversation her progresses!
Best,
Laura Young
Chicago
Musings of an Ant Watcher
Dick Rowan - We like to wait in lines becau
2005-10-26 17:47:34
We like to wait in lines because they are orderly, fair, and have a payoff: wait your turn and you will eventually get something. Lines are confining; for a brief time we don't have to decide where to go. And finally, we crave permission to be close to other humans, even strangers.
Dick Rowan
Falls Church , VA
Rowan on Decision Making
Christian Long - Future Trends in Education
2005-10-26 18:30:33
I want to compliment you on your provocative and well-written column re: the search and hunger for ?authentic experiences.? I have no doubt that once we strip away the marketing and advertising layers so often discussed, we will fnd that the ultimate ?truth? is that ?real? is what people want. It is no surprise that we all will stand in lines to get it, even when there seems to be so many indicators that they might choose an ?easier? path.

I spend a great deal of time with students, educators, school leaders, community members, technology experts, architects, and planners, all in discussions re: the ?future of learning? and how the places, programs, and interactions that will support that must re-think themselves.

Your column used different language, but it was absolutely on-target as to the questions facing ?education? in general.

To that end, I?ve added a post in the ?think:lab? blog to make those connections to your column. If time allows, I?d be interested in your feedback and any insights you may have. Here?s the link:

http://thinklab.typepad.com/think_lab/2005/10/hungry_for_real.html

Thank you for your time and consideration. I continue to appreciate and learn from your regular inputs to the WAG (et al). Keep it up!
Andrew Playford - Your Article Touches on My Bus
2005-10-26 18:31:28
You are discussing something we at Signature Days are trying to build a company around. I truly believe that this next century will be a lot more about experiencing life and our time on this planet and less on hard work and accumulation of ?stuff?.

After all our lives are the sum of each and every day. If each and every day is a missed opportunity so is life.

Andrew
http://thegiftblog.com
http://signaturedays.com
Janet Auty-Carlisle - Winning Hands Down
2005-10-26 18:32:23
Here?s what I have learned. Hands on beats cyber space every time. The net is great for searching, researching, discovering, and for many, staying in touch. When it comes time to do stuff people want hands on. They want to ?experience? the experience. They want to be able to recall, with all their senses, the joys, the sorrows, the laughter, the tears. They want to play, the want to laugh, they want to share that with others. You can?t do that on the net. As was mentioned with the Ipod?kids and other people, want to share experiences. Seeing expressions, hearing the voices, the inflections, the expressions in one?s eyes. That?s what it?s all about. By the way, Andrew, with a name like yours I can?t imagine you doing anything different than teaching people to ?play.?
Bruce Cummings - "terrific reference librarian
2005-10-26 22:21:41
Overall I agree with the article theme, but I found this statement odd: while the online world "has tapped out its usefulness as a static kiosk... it's a terrific reference librarian". As a part-time reference librarian (and full-time school librarian) I have to disagree. A "terrific" reference librarian will not let you dive into the vasty deep of the information ocean and leave you there, grasping at millions of factoids in hopes one will keep you afloat. Rather, through human interaction, a reference librarian will take an opening question like "where is your reference section?" and whittle it down to "where are your test preparation books for the postal worker exam?" (real example). I have yet to see a search engine adequately help my students (who tend to ask overbroad questions) narrow their focus to something specific and meaningful. A live person, trained in reference work, can do that readily.
Francine Hardaway - Meet Fascinating People in Lin
2005-10-28 14:43:31
I wait in lines when the people in line with me are worth meeting. At the Sundance Film Festival, we always wait in line to get into the films, even when we have "packages" of advance tickets. I've met the coolest people in the Sundance lines.
Arden C. Hander - ...Waiting on Queue...
2005-10-31 12:24:02
I must agree with Bruce & Janet that there is nothing like hands-on where research & books are concerned, and that human touch of being able to narrow someone's search to manageability is invaluable. Search engines give unsorted stuff, often irrelevant in that it picks up on only a word of what was entered, and the screen format is definitely not as user-friendly as touching a book: something wqrm about that! Nor is the Internet's value for education what it is cracked up to be. Many campuses are locked into a "blackboard.com" or similar product for class announcements, assignments & due dates, et al., now impersonal rather than personal [and hence inauthentic rather than authentic?]. While we need to push computer literacy & even interactive experiences as preparation for jobs and life, this can only make the gap wider between higher & lower social classes, even with cities like Philadelphia pushing the availablity of 'free' wireless zones for all citizens. And speaking as one who spent four decades of his life teaching in higher education, the Internet brings with it certain flaws. Cheating & plagiarism were never confrontations I enjoyed, but the problems have magnified with the Internet. Software is available & sold to scan papers for sources not identified, and maybe while necessary, it is not a pleasant encounter to enforce the reality of the 'new cheating.' Progress or regression? What about hands-on? And learning as joy?

Standing on queue I(we) do regularly when we go to TKTS for Broadway tickets in NY. It is not just the savings but the experience. We have met & talked to some interesting people while in line. It's the AUTHENTIC of a play that makes it preferred most times over a movie, and PROOF is a good example. The movie loses or minimizes the question of quantum theory which the play made human & palatable. I will, however, allow for an exception without having one to offer. You can get many museums on CD-ROM these days, and that has its place, but you need to go to that museum first to really make it work. It will always be hard, if not impossible, to package the authentic!
Tricia Hoffman - How Lucky to Be Creating REAL
2005-10-31 14:22:18
You wrote, "You give me the tools to make my own personal history, to change my life, to feel in a new way, to participate in something authentic, you will own a piece of economic value."

I?m a very lucky person. I work with people everyday, all day long providing them tools to change their life, feel in a new way, participate in something authentic.? Glad you pointed out the value of this.? It?s something we can all adapt to and not appreciate (your message reminded me of just how lucky I am!).?????Tricia at HeartMath
Write comment
Name:
Title:
UBBCode:
[b] [i] [u] [url] [quote] [code] [img] 
 
Security Image

Powered by JoomlaCommentCopyright (C) 2006 Frantisek Hliva. All rights reserved.Homepage: http://cavo.co.nr/

 
Web Design by Laryn Bakker