Home
- - - - - - -
About David Batstone
Saving the Corporate Soul
Consulting Services
Speaking Events
- - - - - - -
WAG
Right Reality Blog
Articles
Press
- - - - - - -
Contact David Batstone
Store
- - - - - - -
RSS


Subscribe to the WAG
Email:
Zip:
 

 


You Will Be Charged a Fee to Read This Column Print E-mail
Written by David Batstone   

David BatstoneLast year I wrote a column decrying the added fees that were buried in my cellular phone bills. The realization that I had financial parasites discreetly feeding off my cash flow motivated me to start paying more attention to my monthly bills.

So when a "Systems Analysis Charge" of $10 popped up on my monthly statement from US Bank, I suspected unauthorized access to my savings. I did not recall asking for an expert to pour over my "systems." In fact, I did not even realize I owned "systems" - who could guess that my personal checking account suddenly could be so complicated?

I picked up the phone and called my local US Bank branch. The poor woman who answered the phone couldn't figure out what a "Systems Analysis Charge" might mean, either. So she asked if it would be OK to take my phone number and call me back after she had a chance to research the mysterious charge.

Within the hour she had an answer. A client in Australia had wired a payment to my account. Somewhere in the transaction, I lost $25 for wiring fees. I can only assume those fees were levied by the Australian bank that originated the wire. The "Systems Analysis Charge" was an additional fee added on by my bank. The customer service agent explained to me that wires demand so much security these days that, in her words, "a real human being had to run a check on the veracity of the wire."

My sympathy for the bank immediately washed over the annoyance I was feeling at that stage. After all, if a REAL HUMAN BEING had to get involved, I would expect to pay a fee. I fully expect the bank to make revenue off my cash balance to pay for the NON-HUMAN, automatized services that it uses for day-to-day operations. Hey, I bet a real human being in Australia at the originating bank had to input the amount of the wire into a computer...yet another labor-intensive task the bank is justified to defray.

Shifting from cynicism to righteous anger, we're allowing financial institutions to get away with petty theft of our precious cash. Have you used your credit card overseas lately? I have, and Visa charges me a 1 percent charge whether or not a currency conversion was involved. MBNA recently announced that it will levy a 2 percent charge for its customers who shop overseas. Wait, we're not done being fleeced yet. Most major banks then add their own 2 percent charges on top of that, though they don't explain why. I'm guessing that a REAL HUMAN BEING has to get involved at some point of the transaction.

Being forced to pay twice for the right to use money that you will end up paying for anyway - with daily compounded interest - doesn't seem right. But that double-whammy is becoming standard practice. ATM machines have been doing that for years. Perhaps you have come to terms with paying $1.50 for withdrawing cash from another bank's ATM. But why does your own bank then feel justified to add another $1 to $2 surcharge? Several consumer class-action suits are challenging that business practice at present.

According to Business Week, fees will produce close to $2 billion added revenue for banks and $11 billion for credit card companies. Even hotels are getting in the act; they generated around $100 million in fees last year. Case in point: When I checked out from my overnight at a hotel (national chain) in Monterey, California, I noted a $10 "resort fee" added to my room charges. When I asked what my "resort fee" got me, I learned that it gave me access to its "health club" - a 10' x 10' room with a couple of exercise bikes and weight machines, which I didn't use - two water bottles in my room, and unlimited local telephone calls. At least I drank the water. But I got ripped off about $8 for services I didn't use. Am I really going to sit there and argue with the clerk about the charge?

Now, maybe I will. I'm fed up with being nickel-and-dimed to death. Yep, there's a resentment percolating in me, a REAL HUMAN BEING, and I'm ripe for a backlash. The average customer service call costs a company about seven bucks. The relative scarcity of people who do call in and challenge their bank statements - or hotel fees - make that a manageable cost. It's time to change the economics of customer service.

Ready, set, dial. I'll join you on hold.


Comments
Add NewSearchRSS
J Coleman - Excess Fees
2005-05-18 09:52:26
Thanks for your comments, David. I experienced a situation recently which falls into the category of not just excess fees, but USUROUS fees! Was late by two days (travel extended) in paying my AMEX bill and they increased my interest rate on the flexible portion of the bill from 13.9% to 27.74%--and won't change it until I have 12 months of not paying late. And they won't let me, their customer, speak to the people making such decisions!

I think it is time to take ACTION!!
Gil Friend - Excess fees
2005-05-18 11:33:13
Today's SF Chronical business section had a long piece on bank practice of charging fees for "excessive" savings-to-checking transfers, claiming it's required dby Federal law. Turns out... it's not!

PS: Jacking the interest rate in response to late payments falls in a different bucket, IMHO. That's disclosed, and late _is_ late -- separate from the matter of whether the fees are usurious.

- Gil (http://radio.weblogs.com/0109157/)
David - Fees and charges
2005-05-18 13:24:41
Although I totally agree with Mr. Batstone's concern about banks and other businesses levying ridiculous fees, why don't we hold our government leaders to the same standard...and believe me, they take thousands from our paychecks that are wasted on totally inefficient programs or outright pork. We're outraged when the bank hits us with a $ 10 fee, but we can change banks and take our business elsewhere. Where do you go when the government coercively takes thousands from us in taxes and squanders it on furthering their own political power?
L Carn - excess fees
2005-05-18 19:41:56
My bank charged me a deposit fee on my checking acct. because I guess I made too many deposits?! I am also charged for writing too many checks, but for actually GIVING them MY money to use, they can charge me? How is that justifiable?
David Dunn - Bank Fees
2005-05-18 21:42:54
The bank fees show that a tax system that assessed a fee (a progressive fee instead of a flat fee) on all monetary transactions is in fact doable.

The transaction fee could probably start as low as 1% or less and generate more revenue than the federal government would need.

Do away with the income tax and go to a fee for transaction. It's almost like a toll tax. Only it's a tax on the transaction highway.
Mary Bresnahan - credit cards
2005-05-19 21:39:43
Interesting that you write about this. How about a major credit card who charges you a APR if you don't pay your full amount, including the portion that you just received credit on. Doesn't seem right that they get to use my money & then will charge me if I subject the amount credited.
Sure seems like a rip-off to me
N. Ricketts - Unreasonable Policy by Cell Ph
2005-07-21 11:53:00
I recently cancelled my OnStar (GPS) service because I do not drive distances anymore. No problem, and monthly charge was adjusted to reflect actual date of cancellation.
The next step was to cancel Centennial Wireless who provided the phone system for OnStar. They insisted I must write a personal letter to them, even after going through the drill of proving who I really am over the phone, and announced my service would be terminated 30 days after receipt of the letter, and that I would be charged for everyone of the 30 days. I protested by letter .. and talked to them. They said it was "company policy." While I never again will subscribe to Centennial Wireless ... I feel only contempt for the atmostphere of corporate greed that pervades many businesses.
Any how can I fight it? Glad to know of your column!
Write comment
Name:
Title:
UBBCode:
[b] [i] [u] [url] [quote] [code] [img] 
 
Security Image

Powered by JoomlaCommentCopyright (C) 2006 Frantisek Hliva. All rights reserved.Homepage: http://cavo.co.nr/

 
Web Design by Laryn Bakker