Warning: Call-time pass-by-reference has been deprecated in /home/rightrea/rightreality.com/mambots/content/joscomment.php on line 43

Warning: Call-time pass-by-reference has been deprecated in /home/rightrea/rightreality.com/components/com_comment/joscomment/board.php on line 47

Warning: Call-time pass-by-reference has been deprecated in /home/rightrea/rightreality.com/components/com_comment/joscomment/form.php on line 98

Warning: Call-time pass-by-reference has been deprecated in /home/rightrea/rightreality.com/components/com_comment/joscomment/form.php on line 99
What Young Workers Really Want
Written by David Batstone   

David BatstoneWorkers in their 20s are giving their employers fits.

Managers frequently vent to me their frustration with a new generation entering the workforce. A hospital director in the Midwest put it this way: "I give my young workers instructions how to complete a task, and they have no qualms telling me that they don't want to do it that way."

The 20-something worker indeed has a unique approach to authority. They do not as a rule show disdain, or even rebellion, but tend to elevate their own opinion to an equal plane with a boss or supervisor. In that regard, they are accustomed to having a voice that counts. Titles and hierarchy mean much less to them than it did for earlier generations.

The threat of losing their job is not quite as daunting to this generation, either. They have grown up in an affluent era, so perhaps they take financial security for granted. Yet it is also the case that they are not willing to sacrifice their lifestyle and personal identity for a paycheck. For that reason, managers who are using the old carrot-and-stick approach with this crowd do not find much success.

Above all, younger workers are less likely to channel their passions into a job. They are apt to see work as a means to an end. The work week gets them to the weekend, and that's when the fun begins. They are wise to the transitional economy. They know that employers will not show them loyalty over the long-term - they have watched their parents pass through an uncertain career. So they see the job as a short-term contract that can be renewed, by both parties, as long as both parties are satisfied. This generation serves as its own free agent.

A few months ago, Mel Levine, a professor of child development and learning at the University of North Carolina, published a fascinating essay in the Chronicle for Higher Education. He argued with candor that college graduates are unprepared for the world of work. Here's a brief excerpt from the piece:

"In conducting interviews for my new book, Ready or Not, Here Comes Life, I heard repeatedly from employers that their current crop of novice employees appear unable to delay gratification and think long-term. They have trouble starting at the bottom rung of a career ladder and handling the unexciting detail, the grunt work, and the political setbacks they have to bear. In fact, many contemporary college and graduate students fail to identify at all with the world of adults."

It's a time-honored sport for an older generation to decry the potential of the newest pups on the block, of course. To his credit, Levine goes on in the essay to indicate how young people are the products of how we parent and educate in this society.

I see that truth most clearly as a Little League coach. I am convinced that children will rise to the expectations that you set for them in a supportive environment. So I reward kids as they succeed at a new level of skill development - their own skill development. I often hear from parents of the kids: "Could you please play Larry at shortstop today? It would be so good for his self-esteem." Well, Larry will feel better about himself - and the team will feel better about Larry - when he focuses on his skills and is recognized for that effort.

You clearly don't treat a college graduate entering the workforce like a Little League kid. But young workers do appreciate candor about the terms of engagement. The more they see their own self-expression and development recognized, the greater will be their connection to the company. An appeal to the universal duty of Work - "you should appreciate that you've got a job and work hard" - just won't cut it.

Managers also will have better success with the 20-something generation whenthey offer fluid job descriptions. They do not want to be a cog in the machine, easily replaced by the next sap who walks in the door. That doesn't mean that managers must compromise their position. Young people need leadership and structure as much as the rest of the workforce. Managers, you set the team's priorities then ask the workers what part they can play to make the team successful. The more younger workers can throw their passions into their tasks, the better will be their performance.

Overall, the 20-something generation is driving us to bring more imagination and democracy into the workplace. Now that's not such a bad thing, is it?

Comments
Add NewSearch
Lacey - What Young Workers Really Want
2005-06-22 11:18:34
As a young (25) worker myself, I can tell you that my generation is mostly looking for a place to grow, learn, and be creative. As a younger generation, we certainly have a lot of new ideas, and often these ideas are pushed aside as "novice" or "not how we do it here" or even "just cute, but welcome to the real world." This can be very frustrating, especially because we were raised to be very independent and creative thinkers. We were always told "your opinion matters," and "try new things." But, I am finding that an older generation is much slower to adopt new things.

This is especially frustrating in areas where new growth and ideas are needed. Areas like education and arts. These are fields where the "tried and true" way is beginning to fail - our community has stopped responding, and new ideas are needed to refresh and revitalize us. Even in business, we have been taught that the workplace should be horizontal, not vertical. We have studied case after case of these organizations, and feel we should be working in a horizontal company too. One where our voice is at least heard as an equal.

The biggest problem (which may also be a strength), I am the first to admit, is that we want to have the answers. Our ideas are new, and may not work, but we don't know that. We aren't in a place to instill these new values and perspectives into the workplace, but we want to see the change happen almost immediately. We want to take something and run with it, but don't have the experience and know-how to really make it happen.

My advice to employers - listen to the newbies in your workforce. You certainly don't have to let them do everything their own way, but allow a little freedom to try out new ideas, and give feedback that may make the new way more successful. A blending of the old and the new often creates the best product. If you give a little in one area, your younger employees are likely to feel envigorated by that project and more interested in finishing the rest of the grunt work and other duties you are prescribing for them. We just need something to be our own, or something to give us hope in our own personal growth within the company or field we are entering. Give us a chance, and we may just surprise you with our loyalty and work ethic.
Rodney North - What Young Workers Really Want
2005-06-22 12:06:57
I'm not a young worker, but about 1/2 of my colleagues are, and in our 80 employee company (Equal Exchange) I don't see the trends that David describes. And maybe that is precisely because we do in fact operate as an democratic workplace*. More specifically we're a worker-owned cooperative, and in the end, the employees call the shots (at least for the most important matters). But also we're a mission-driven company (an admittedly over-used phrase & claim, but if the shoe fits . . .). Consequently, I think, our young staff seem to accept the trade-off of a) doing the grunt work, the repetative tasks, etc, but also b) being a part of making a change in the world, and knowing that they are listened to, both as employees, and as owners of the firm.

Maybe our co-op is an exception to the norm that heps to prove David's point, that young workers CAN make a long term commitment, and just might throw themselves into their work WHEN both they, and the work, matter.

(*Not to be nit-picky but I couldn't help but notice that while David advocated "bringing democracy to the workplace" nothing in his article actually touched upon "democracy" - ie ultimate authority residing with the community (ie employees); elected leadership; transparency; accountability; 1 person/1 vote, etc.. Rather David seems to be encouraging that young workers be given opportunities for dialogue w/management, & for participation and maybe some more individual autonomy. All good things, but they don't constitute 'democracy'.
Paula Parker - What Young Workers Really Want
2005-06-22 12:44:30
As a twenty-something (26) in the work force, I immediately identified with Batstone's article. I was intrigued by the concept that "they" are accustomed to having a voice that counts, titles and hierarchy mean much less to them, not biting at the old carrot of losing their job, not wanting to be just another cog, and the impatient ideas flooding to their lips--I didn't realize it was any other way!

Maybe I should discretely post this article for the benefit of my older management. Perhaps, also, considering how my older management population in the company views how workers "should" behave will help us come to some common ground, where we can blend our novice-youth outlook with their time-tempered experience and dilligence.

Thanks for the insight--it should get me to the weekend.
Patricia - What Young Workers Want
2005-06-22 18:42:22
You hit the nail on the head.

I'm in my late 20s and left my "safe" corporate job a year ago to become an independent marketing consultant. They thought I was a warm body that didn't need development, encouragement, pay raises, or a future.

I made the leap very successfully and couldn't be happier. I have more personal time AND a fulfilling career where I'm paid well for the work I do.

I don't anticipate going back to the "safety" of a corporation anytime soon.
David J. - Virtual to Real World
2005-06-23 13:07:00
All you said is certainly true. I?d just like to add one additional observation/theory

How much of their behavior is also influenced by their video-gaming? In a game, while they work within rules and limitations, they are left to learn these as they go along.

Even my young soccer players learn this way, as we dump them on the field after just two practices.

In the long run, I think this will make them excellent workers.
Stephanie - What Young Workers Really Want
2005-06-23 19:11:46
I can relate to the values of younger workers looking for work experiences where they feel valued, but I've also been one of those older managers trying to figure out how to best use youthful innovation and creativity untempered by the life wisdom.

Older managers should be receptive to new ideas, but younger workers should also bring respect to the workplace. One limitation of youth is that you sometimes don't know what you don't know. This lack of awareness can be a challenge for everyone -- for the young worker who wants to exert greater influence, and for the manager who has to weigh the needs of the organization against the needs of the individual employee.

In recent years, I've encountered a few younger workers who treated me like a peer, not realizing that I did not perceive them as one. Does it matter? Only if you're the younger person hoping to be respected by the older one.
Steve Chichester - What young workers really want
2005-06-27 02:19:25
The comments and observations made here are quite similar to those made in, "In Search of Excellence" 25 or so years ago. Ken Blanchard, I think. And 40 yrs would be closer. Including that young people no longer bought into being secure in a postion or company till retirement.

And the solutions of identifying jobs to be done to achieve a goal, then finding out which each staff member was interested in, and asssigning it to that member if possible, were in that book too.

The choice between management as facilitators vs. dictators is probably as old as humanity has existed. The "discovery" of that "alternative" mangement style recurs, I suspect, in every generation.

Everyone works for their own satisfation. Always have, always will. The easiest form of management has always been to find where peoples interests lie, and put them in a position where they can satisfy those interests, if possible. Inner directed, self motivated performers.

Jim Ware - The Future of Work
2005-06-28 16:25:57
Great insight into the wants and expectations of younger workers, as well as good advice on how to manage them. But, as I argue on the Future of Work blog (http://www.thefutureofwork.net/blog/archives/000231.html), all workers, not just young ones, are shifting towards these values. If you want to attract and retain talent at any age, start revamping your management practices now, before it?s too late.
John - Commitment Goes Both Ways
2005-06-30 01:16:48
Why should any worker have a long term commitment to a company when the company has no such long term commitment to the worker? I mean, they SAY they do, and then there?s one bad quarter and it?s layoff city. Can there be such a thing as a ?career ladder? when there are layoffs every couple of years?
Energy28 - Work Ethic
2005-07-01 08:58:43
Management is dead. Democracy in the workplace should not even be debated. Organizations who continue to use the so-called ?work ethic? in their culture won?t last.

I don?t want to be a worker. I want to be involved in the decisions that affect my life.
Robert Cenek - Not much changes
2005-07-13 03:07:14
I somewhat share Jim Ware?s sentiments. My take is that the Organization Man has been slowly withering for several decades.

Jim Massey made a fortune highlighting generational differences (way back in the late 70?s.) Today?s so-called Generation X?er is really not that much different from other cohorts of the last several decades.
Only registered users can write comments!