|
Workers in their 20s are giving their employers fits.
Managers frequently vent to me their frustration with a new generation
entering the workforce. A hospital director in the Midwest put it this
way: "I give my young workers instructions how to complete a task, and
they have no qualms telling me that they don't want to do it that way."
The 20-something worker indeed has a unique approach to authority. They
do not as a rule show disdain, or even rebellion, but tend to elevate
their own opinion to an equal plane with a boss or supervisor. In that
regard, they are accustomed to having a voice that counts. Titles and
hierarchy mean much less to them than it did for earlier generations.
The threat of losing their job is not quite as daunting to this
generation, either. They have grown up in an affluent era, so perhaps
they take financial security for granted. Yet it is also the case that
they are not willing to sacrifice their lifestyle and personal identity
for a paycheck. For that reason, managers who are using the old
carrot-and-stick approach with this crowd do not find much success.
Above all, younger workers are less likely to channel their passions
into a job. They are apt to see work as a means to an end. The work
week gets them to the weekend, and that's when the fun begins. They are
wise to the transitional economy. They know that employers will not show them
loyalty over the long-term - they have watched their parents pass
through an uncertain career. So they see the job as a short-term
contract that can be renewed, by both parties, as long as both parties
are satisfied. This generation serves as its own free agent.
A few months ago, Mel Levine, a professor of child development and
learning at the University of North Carolina, published a fascinating
essay in the Chronicle for Higher Education. He argued with candor that
college graduates are unprepared for the world of work. Here's a brief
excerpt from the piece:
"In conducting interviews for my new book, Ready or Not, Here Comes
Life, I heard repeatedly from employers that their current crop of
novice employees appear unable to delay gratification and think
long-term. They have trouble starting at the bottom rung of a career
ladder and handling the unexciting detail, the grunt work, and the
political setbacks they have to bear. In fact, many contemporary
college and graduate students fail to identify at all with the world of
adults."
It's a time-honored sport for an older generation to decry the
potential of the newest pups on the block, of course. To his credit,
Levine goes on in the essay to indicate how young people are the
products of how we parent and educate in this society.
I see that truth most clearly as a Little League coach. I am convinced
that children will rise to the expectations that you set for them in a
supportive environment. So I reward kids as they succeed at a new level
of skill development - their own skill development. I often hear from
parents of the kids: "Could you please play Larry at shortstop today?
It would be so good for his self-esteem." Well, Larry will feel better
about himself - and the team will feel better about Larry - when he
focuses on his skills and is recognized for that effort.
You clearly don't treat a college graduate entering the workforce like
a Little League kid. But young workers do appreciate candor about the
terms of engagement. The more they see their own self-expression and
development recognized, the greater will be their connection to the
company. An appeal to the universal duty of Work - "you should
appreciate that you've got a job and work hard" - just won't cut it.
Managers also will have better success with the 20-something generation
whenthey offer fluid job descriptions. They do not want to be a cog in
the machine, easily replaced by the next sap who walks in the door.
That doesn't mean that managers must compromise their position. Young
people need leadership and structure as much as the rest of the
workforce. Managers, you set the team's priorities then ask the workers
what part they can play to make the team successful. The more younger
workers can throw their passions into their tasks, the better will be
their performance.
Overall, the 20-something generation is driving us to bring more
imagination and democracy into the workplace. Now that's not such a bad
thing, is it?
|