Warning: Call-time pass-by-reference has been deprecated in /home/rightrea/rightreality.com/mambots/content/joscomment.php on line 43

Warning: Call-time pass-by-reference has been deprecated in /home/rightrea/rightreality.com/components/com_comment/joscomment/board.php on line 47

Warning: Call-time pass-by-reference has been deprecated in /home/rightrea/rightreality.com/components/com_comment/joscomment/form.php on line 98

Warning: Call-time pass-by-reference has been deprecated in /home/rightrea/rightreality.com/components/com_comment/joscomment/form.php on line 99
Customer Service Where You Most Expect It
Written by David Batstone   

Hospitals cannot afford to deliver patient care.

That statement sounds like an oxymoron, but it conveys the true struggle for health care providers today.

Let's be honest, the same goes for most any business. Customer service has become an endangered species on the expense line. I like the way that Carol Hymowitz phrased it in the title for her Wall Street Journal column this past week: "Everyone Likes to Laud Serving the Customer; Doing It Is the Problem."

My sister Linda works in the health care field and is passionate about finding better ways to provide quality health care. She raved to me about the work of Lolma Olson, a consultant that she brought in to assist her with patient care at her hospital in Minneapolis. Ms. Olson has the right pedigree. She was the director of patient relations and organizational development at a major medical center in San Francisco for 15 years. Today Ms. Olson runs her own firm, Sage Consulting, headquartered in Northern California. I called her up to pick her brain on practices to improve customer care without blowing the budget.

Ms. Olson focuses on a basic element of customer care: building connected relationships with your clients. At first blush that may seem obvious, but she found that it was the lack of consistency in relationships that dogs health care. Providers offer plenty of structure for deploying clinical tasks but it does not do so for building relationships.

So she developed a system she calls First Touch. The initial step is to train every health care provider - be it the doctor, nurse, physical therapist or orderly - to make a non-clinical connection with a patient. That means making medication trays and clipboards invisible, and to sit at eye level with the patient. When she first introduces this practice, many professionals offer resistance for a range of reasons. Some professionals worry that the patient will expect more from the relationship than the health care provider can give them and they will fall behind the demands of their schedule. Others hide behind the clinical task, and admit not knowing what to say to some patients once a conversation unfolds.

Ms. Olson discovered early on a certain fatalism among hospital managers. They assume that some individuals are gifted with social skills and others aren't. "The best we can do," grumble the managers, "is give people a script to say the right thing and follow performance standards."

Ms. Olson challenges that notion, and pinpoints the failure of customer service elsewhere: "We haven't put the heart into customer service," she notes. "The script is not going to work if there is nothing motivating the employee to say it!"

First Touch shows health care providers how to incorporate four principles into their daily practice:

1) Demonstrate that you are being present for the patient at that moment;

2) Offer the best of yourself to the best of the people you serve;

3) Become less judgmental of those you serve;

4) Begin the relationship with a personal greeting and close it with a good-bye (at the end of a session or a shift).

Ms. Olson stresses that professionals can set boundaries on the relationships. They can inform the patient of their busy schedule, yet make a connection for the time that they have with any given individual. Even the slightest human touch helps to minimize the fear of a patient.

Once these practices become a part of the culture, a number of tangible benefits emerge. Patient satisfaction surveys show a marked improvement; over a period of two years, patient satisfaction moves from the 40th percentile to the 90th percentile for most of Ms. Olson's health care provider clients. Call light use drops noticeably by both patients and their families. Note that both these factors have major financial implications on the revenue and cost side, respectively. The hospital faces less "customer recovery" for disgruntled cases and more referrals for delivering excellent care.

The benefit of First Touch for employees also needs to be underscored. Although health care workers often report that they entered their career to make a difference, the trivialization of caring relationships depressed their motivation. Ms. Olson reports that professionals who practice First Touch feel more engaged and find meaning in their work. "Last week a hospital manager in Albuquerque told me that First Touch is renewing her passion for her practice," says Ms. Olson.

The lesson of First Touch demonstrates that excellent service may not be how much time you spend with customers, but how you spend your time.

To learn more about Lolma Olson and First Touch, visit Sage Consulting.

Comments
Add NewSearch
Rev. Ruth Shaver - First Touch
2006-03-02 09:47:45
First Touch customer service sounds like ministry to me. By elevating the "customer" to first place, service providers become what we are all called to be, servants to others. Relationship is so important in every field; I dare say that businesses which promote relationships will begin to see immediate gains from their attention to the individual on the other end, whether face-to-face, by telephone, or even by e-mail.
Discipula - Funny thing happ'd on the way
2006-03-02 09:56:48
The first line, something about 'can't afford customer service' is somewhat cleared up at the end re: a list of things that can be done without added expense.
However: here is the cardinal, or first, rule of business:
"You cannot *afford* poor customer service; not here or there; not then or now."

I've been in hospitals that act like the Dept. of Parking and Traffic (civil servant mentality); yet, I've been in hospitals that have employed actual humans. There's no mystery here: verbal man-handling reaps hostility, which reaps "I'll never go back there again."
No amount of efficiency seminars, or 'brainstorming' sessions by mgmt can supply the one thing every business must have: quick, extra-mile, pleasant, and down-home 'we treat you right' customer service.
Maria Palma - Connecting with humans key
2006-03-03 01:12:12
Of all industries, I believe the health care industry should really pay attention to how they treat their customers. Connecting with humans is a basic fundamental skill that everybody should have.

Thanks for the article. I?ve referenced it at my customer service blog:CustomersAreAlways.com
Steve Meloan - Greed and the Customer
2006-03-09 14:23:23
I can't help but think that part of the problem is simple corporate greed. As a result of an association with the USC business school, I've come to know Paul Orfalea, the found of the Kinko's Copy Store empire. While forming and running Kinko's (it's now owned by FedEx), Paul always had the utmost respect for his employees and their needs, believing that doing so was the bedrock of running a successful company. He's a major donor to the local hospital in his area of Southern California. When he learned that nurses at the hospital were not attending the annual charitable fundraising night, he paid the fees necessary for them to attend. The point being that it was insane not to include the core service providers of the business.

He's also a big booster of working mothers. Whenever he gives money to a university for a building, he insists that it include "lactation stations." But his is a rare outlook in the corporate world. I remember reading an interview with him in the Southwest Airlines magazine. He was talking about daycare programs for working mothers, how it really wasn't all that expensive for a large corporation, because Uncle Sam was "subsidizing the hell out of you." When's the last time you heard a corporate CEO talk like that?

Steve Meloan - McDonald's Style Health Care
2006-03-09 14:25:27
David wrote: "The benefit of First Touch for employees also needs to be underscored. Although health care workers often report that they entered their career to make a difference, the trivialization of caring relationships depressed their motivation. Ms. Olson reports that professionals who practice First Touch feel more engaged and find meaning in their work. 'Last week a hospital manager in Albuquerque told me that First Touch is renewing her passion for her practice,' says Ms. Olson."

I think medical managerial forces often lose sight of the end purpose of their business -- providing health care. They see themselves as businessmen who just happen to work in the health care arena. They set time goals for patient interactions as if the nurses were filling orders at McDonald's.
Katherine Pittman - Making the most of our time
2006-03-17 00:16:50
I believe you are right on target. I do not think we will ever get more time. We can, however, make the most of the time we have. Do you have other information to share on how to implement this practice globally?
Only registered users can write comments!